Would YOU try a ‘tolyamorous’ relationship? TRACEY COX speaks to women who turn a blind eye to infidelity (and reveals how it can even improve your marriage)

‘My husband kept nagging me for sex. It was unbearable – then suddenly it stopped.

“It was clear he got it from somewhere else, but we never talked about it. I don’t ask questions when he comes home late, and we get along better. It’s an arrangement that suits us both.”

It’s an unconventional situation, but if you’re willing to cheat when your partner cheats in order to save your relationship, then you’re “tolyamorous.”

Dan Savage, an American columnist and podcaster (Savage Love), coined the term to describe relationships in which one or both partners tolerate the other person outside of sexual or romantic contact.

It is not an open relationship because the couple has never acknowledged or discussed the infidelity. Instead, one of them looks the other way and pretends nothing is happening.

Socially, the couple continues to behave monogamously, even if the relationship is not.

‘Tolyamoury’ describes relationships in which one or both partners tolerate the other’s infidelity

TOLYAMORY IS MORE COMMON THAN YOU THINK

It sounds unsavory, but tolyamory has been around as long as marriage. It just has a catchy name now.

This type of relationship is most common when there is already a clear exchange: one person has a lot of money and power and the other gets to enjoy his or her privileges and lifestyle… as long as they accept certain things.

It also happens a lot in relationships where breaking up doesn’t suit either of you. Why did Hillary Clinton stay with Bill when his infidelity came to light? Because staying with him helped her political aspirations.

As Dan Savage points out, tolyamory doesn’t necessarily mean that one person is being fooled or abused. There are circumstances where it works out perfectly for both.

Relationship and sex expert Tracey Cox (pictured) explains that tolyamoury is not the same as an open relationship, as the couple has never acknowledged or discussed infidelity

“I would rather have him and accept the cheating than not have him at all.”

Laura is 34 and has been married for eight years.

“I don’t think I’m pretty enough for my husband to want just me. He loves me and he loves our kids and I have no doubt that we’re the things he cares about most in the world. But he’s always liked to look at beautiful, overtly sexy women and I don’t fit that mold.

He is 36, very handsome, has a successful business, travels a lot and women are attracted to him. I knew he might go a step further than just looking when I married him. But I have been in love with him since day one and honestly I would rather have him and put up with the cheating than not have him at all. I have a great lifestyle, a beautiful home, I don’t want for anything and my children have all the advantages I wanted for them. It’s a fair trade when you look at it that way.

That’s how I feel now, of course. I’m used to it now. The first time I realized he was cheating, it broke me. His best friend’s wife tried to warn me. She made a few comments about how you can’t trust men and how she worries about what her husband gets up to when he’s on business with me. She’d caught him cheating before. She looked at my face to see how I was reacting. She might as well have said her husband told her mine was cheating.

Some people choose to stay because the thought of life without their partner – even if he or she is unfaithful – is too awful to contemplate (stock image)

I didn’t say much, just nodded and said something like, “Boys will be boys,” but inside I was dying. The kids were little—two and three—and I was fragile. I still had some baby weight on me and didn’t look my best. My husband noticed I was upset on the way home and asked what was wrong. I don’t know why I didn’t tell him and ask him directly if he was planning something. But I didn’t.

I talked to another good friend about it and she said that all the men in our group sleep with other women from time to time. It’s the norm. None of the women call them out on it because they know they’re doing fine in every other way.

I don’t think my husband is like the rest of them. I have no doubt that he really loves us. I think this is something he’ll do when he’s young and he won’t be interested in doing later. It’s a waiting game and as long as I know I have his heart, I’m willing to play it.’

WHY TOLYAMORY IS SUITABLE FOR SOME COUPLES

Sometimes the positive aspects make cheating bearable. It can even improve the relationship. Especially if…

You don’t want sex with your partner and are fine with that need being met elsewhere. I see it a lot with couples with a mismatched libido. One wants a lot of sex, the other doesn’t want sex at all. They didn’t start out that way, but they’ve gotten to this point after a long time together. If you love your partner but don’t want to have sex with him or her or want to deny him or her pleasure, outsourcing sex is a solution to the problem.

You don’t want to lose or jeopardize your lifestyle or income. Divorce usually means dividing what you have in half – at the very least, it means losing some material possessions. If marrying someone with a high income was important to you, living the lifestyle you want may be more important than having a faithful spouse.

You don’t want to upset your children and family. Not wanting to hurt your children is probably the most common reason for tolyamory. Ending a long-term relationship is complicated, messy, and heartbreaking. And it’s not just the children whose world falls apart, it’s everyone around you. Mutual friends, parents, and siblings suffer; grandparents worry about jeopardizing their access to grandchildren; friends worry about having to choose sides. Breaking up with your family can be more painful than breaking up with your partner.

You can’t imagine life without your partner and you would rather tolerate cheating than live without him or her. A very sad reason to stay, but for some people better than the alternative.

The relationship has grown into a close friendship. You don’t want sex anymore, but she does. Older couples sometimes slip into this arrangement without ever approving or discussing it. You love them enough not to want to deny them something they truly enjoy.

‘If I confront him and he agrees to end the affair, I will have to have sex with him again’

Sarah, 43, has two children and has been married for 15 years.

‘I just found out I’m in a tolyamorous relationship. I’d never heard that term until you asked people about their stories.

My husband and I were close, but drifted apart over the years. Sex was never our strong suit, but we did it regularly – twice a month – which I think is not bad considering our age and stage. About two years ago, my husband stopped initiating sex, and then completely. I know that sounds awful, but I was relieved. Sex in marriage is boring: everyone knows that. We didn’t acknowledge that sex was ending in our relationship, and in retrospect, we should have, because it was between us and making everything awkward. Every word about sex is painful now. When someone makes a joke about sex, we laugh along, but it makes us both want to sink through the floor.

I guess I should have thought about what he would do if he didn’t get sex from me. I assumed he would watch porn and take care of himself. That was naive: it didn’t occur to me that he would seek sex outside of marriage, because as far as I’m concerned, we can do just fine without it.

That’s the difference between men and women. Women are secretly relieved when sex stops. But sex is important to men, even men who don’t really have a huge appetite.

My husband is friends with a woman he works with. I met her and we hit it off. I picked up his phone a month ago and found a text exchange between them that left nothing to the imagination. It seems they have been having sex for a year or more. I was shocked, but not horrified, if that makes sense. Of course he gets it from somewhere else, if he doesn’t pester me about it. He’s 45, not 75!

He doesn’t hide his phone from me: I think he thinks I won’t check the texts he gets from someone I know is a friend of his.

I haven’t said anything because I don’t know what to do. I don’t think he’s in love with this woman, it’s clearly just friends with benefits. My practical side can see that it’s a solution to a problem. But I also feel betrayed and like I’ve been made a fool of by both of them. If I tell him I know and he agrees to stop, I’ll have to have sex with him again and I don’t want that. I’m tempted to keep my mouth shut and see what happens. Maybe it’ll just fizzle out. I certainly don’t want it to end in a rift between us. It would break my children’s hearts and that’s something I’m not prepared to do.’

WHY IT DESTROYS OTHERS

In the past, women were more likely to be expected to tolerate their husbands’ indiscretions. Closing the infidelity gap means that both sexes can now find themselves in this situation.

As you can imagine, tolyamory has many disadvantages.

May cause emotional distress. If you look the other way because your self-confidence is shattered and you feel you don’t deserve respect from your partner, that’s clearly not a good solution. The same goes if it makes you feel betrayed, sad and lonely.

Confidence is declining. Trust is the cornerstone of a healthy relationship – and you don’t just need it for sex and love. You need to be able to trust your partner to do the right thing for you, to handle shared finances responsibly, to be a good parent, and to behave well with the people you love. Losing trust in one area can undermine it in others.

There are health risks if your partner does not have safe sex.

Resentment and bitterness can build over time. It’s not easy to stay faithful long term. Take away the morals and consequences and we’d probably all have a lustful affair every now and then. What holds us back is commitment, our moral code and doing the “right” thing for our partner. It’s not easy to see your partner having their cake and eating it too when you’re denying yourself a piece.

  • Check out Tracey’s two product lines, Tracey Cox Edge and Supersex, at lovehoney.co.uk.
Related Post